Spring Return (Single Acting) vs Double Acting Valve Actuators

In typical application of the ball valve, control valve, and choke valve, there are two types of actuator that is used, the spring return (or single acting) actuator and the double acting actuator. The spring return actuator is the actuator that used spring force to place the valve position in close or open position. We only need to pressurize on one side only to operate the valve. The double acting actuator is the actuator that only use piston as its element to operate the valve. We need to pressurize both side of the actuator alternately to operate the valve. See below drawing that illustrates the spring return and double acting actuators. Now the question is, when we will use this spring return actuator and when we will use the double acting actuator?

Torque or Thrust Strength

Typically for offshore oil and gas application the thrust or torque strength of the spring return and double acting actuator isn’t a problem. Even though some actuator manufacturer usually shown that double acting actuator has higher thrust or torque strength compare with spring return actuator, the difference is only exist in the very high thrust or torque application which is normally not exist in the offshore application. Thus, we can say that both of it is having an equal strength of thrust or torque.

Safety Integrated System Application

In most of safety system application such as shutdown valve (SDV), blow down valve (BDV), etc, that require the valve to become in close position or in open position when the signal or the supply is lost, then the spring return is the choice. The spring return type is the best choice for safety application due to its simplicity and reliability. Actually the double acting actuators is also possible for the fail close or fail open application, but the local panel arrangement will be more complex compare with the spring return type.

Fail in Last Position

There are some applications that require the valve to become in last position when the signal or the supply is lost such as production choke valve. The choke valve typical fail position is fail last position to keep the last production rate. In the case fail last position is required, then the best choice is double acting actuator. The valve is kept in last position by pressurize both side of the actuator thus it will kept the valve in its last position.

Control Application

In the process control application that use control valve as its final control element, the typical actuator is diaphragm spring return diaphragm for the small valve up to 8 inch. While when it is 10 inch and above the actuator is double acting type to overcome the required high thrust. The double acting actuator is also used when the application is very high application to overcome the required high thrust even though the size is smaller than 10 inch. This double acting actuator is more stiff and stable for control application especially for application that has a sudden change in process condition. While when we use the diaphragm spring return type, the thrust on the other side is always the same by the spring. While when we use the double acting actuator, the other side forces will be managed by the positioner pressure output as per actual conditions.

Here is the summary of the spring return (single acting) vs. the double acting valve actuators selection:

Application	Spring Return	Double Acting
Torque or Thrust	Low to High	Low to Very High
Safety Integrated   System(SDV, BDV)	Simple, Reliable,   Best Choices	A little bit   complex, Secondary Choices
Fail in Last   Position(Choke Valve)	More expensive,   secondary choices	Best choices
Control application(Control Valve,   Choke Valve)	Best for 8 inch size   and below	Best for 10 inch   size and above, also for high pressure applications.

Source: Spring Return (Single Acting) vs Double Acting Actuators